McKinney

McKinneyWeekly.news — Historic charm. News from McKinney's neighborhoods.

Back to McKinney

We Checked the Recall Math. The 5,805 Number Is Exactly Right.

Organizers say they need 5,805 signatures. The county's official canvass shows why: 19,350 ballots were counted in McKinney's last regular city election, and 30 percent of that is 5,805 to the digit.

Cody Esparza

August 18, 20262 min read

Civic Verification - illustration, Jake Team LLC

The recall petition circulating in McKinney needs 5,805 valid signatures. That figure has been repeated in nearly every story about the effort, always attributed to the campaign. We checked it against the county's official records, and it is exactly right.

Where the number comes from

McKinney's home rule charter requires a recall petition to carry signatures equal to at least 30% of the votes cast at the last regular municipal election, with a floor of 1,000.

That election was May 3, 2025. According to Collin County's official final summary report, the McKinney mayoral contest recorded 19,147 votes cast plus 203 undervotes, for contest totals of 19,350 ballots.

Thirty percent of 19,350 is 5,805. Not approximately. Exactly.

Why the base year is easy to get wrong

The obvious assumption would be that the threshold keys off the most recent May election. It does not, because McKinney did not hold one.

The county's official summary for the May 2, 2026 joint election runs 19 pages and covers Allen, Anna, Celina, Frisco, Princeton, Lucas, Murphy, Parker, Sachse and others. McKinney appears nowhere in it. Countywide turnout that day was 7.13%, with 28,671 ballots cast among 401,916 registered voters.

So the arithmetic reaches back to May 2025, when the mayor's race drew far more interest than a typical city election.

What that election looked like

Bill Cox led the May 2025 mayoral field with 8,957 votes, or 46.78%, short of the majority needed to win outright. Scott Sanford took 7,813 votes, or 40.81%. Taylor Willingham and Matt "Doc" Rostami drew 1,268 and 1,109. Cox won the office in a runoff the following month.

Ernest Lynch, one of the three council members named in the petition alongside Cox, won the At-Large No. 1 seat with 5,027 votes, or 29.33% of 17,139 cast in a five-candidate race.

The practical size of the task

Organizers have until 5 p.m. Saturday, Sept. 26 to gather the signatures, on numbered pages issued by the City Secretary, signed in ink and in person by registered voters living inside the city limits, with a trained circulator present for each one. The committee has said it is aiming for 7,500 to leave room for signatures that get invalidated.

Put against the 2025 turnout, 5,805 signatures is close to two thirds of the total vote Cox received when he led that mayoral field, and it must be collected in 45 days rather than an election season.

The City Secretary examines the petition after it is submitted. Only if it is certified, and a named officer does not resign within the period the charter allows, does the question of a recall election reach the council.

The city has not issued a public statement about the recall, and none appears in its news releases.

Sources: Collin County Elections official summary reports, May 3, 2025 and May 2, 2026; McKinney Recall Committee.

Sources

https://www.collincountytx.gov/docs/default-source/elections/results-archive/may-3-2025-election-summary-results-report-official-final.pdf

https://www.collincountytx.gov/docs/default-source/elections/results-archive/may-2-2026---joint-election---summary-report----official-results.pdf

https://mckinneyrecall.com/

Share

Cody Esparza

Cody Esparza covers McKinney city hall, the council, and county government.

Related Stories

More in Texas